Surviving A Multi-Opponent Attack
Maneuvering For Advantage:
by Christopher Caile
Editor's note: This is the fifth of a series of articles
exploring principles, tactics and techniques that can be used when confronted
with multiple attackers.
4 - The Noose
There are times when three or more attackers are up close as in an elevator,
hallway or entrance area. This example is similar to one in the last article,
"The Loose Half Circle," but here there is virtually no room
If the attackers start the action, an attack could come from any direction
or all directions at once. Thus, here more than ever, taking the initiative
is necessary to give you a slight edge. Of course, be sure those burly
friends who are getting up close and friendly are really there to attack
you. An unprovoked assault against a group of visiting Russian wrestlers
wouldn't be greeted in a friendly fashion, and law enforcement wouldn't
be friendly either. So check your signals. Be sure before you act.
The closer the attackers are to you, and the more people there are, the
more you have to condense your techniques and movement to be successful.
This means doing two, three or more things at once, as part of the same
movement. This cuts time and technically gives you a small edge. And,
even if the space is tight you can often still move a little to create
room to launch techniques, or to create a small distance between you and
at least one attacker.
This scenario begins just as the action is starting when you have a little
time to take the offensive. Being grabbed and jumped on will be covered
later. Here, you, the defender, are confronted in a very tight space,
an elevator. There are three men around you and the man facing you in
the middle reaches out to push your chest.
seen in the second photo you move against the man who reached out to push
you. Your technique is not a hard strike, but a lightening fast finger
flick to the eyes (known as Splashing Hands in many Kung Fu systems).
The particular technique is not important. It could be a technique to
the testicles, a finger jab to the throat, a fast knuckle strike to the
side of the noise, or even pocket change thrown into the person's face.
You are trying at minimum to cause a defensive reflex or distraction that
will momentarily freeze the person in front.
In this instance you use the fingers of your right hand to flick the
eyes. While not bringing permanent injury, this technique can shock, disorientate,
and cause pain and eye watering.
But, this is not your only technique. If you do just this and just stand
there waiting, or turn to face another attacker, someone else will attack
you in an instant, and it may be from behind. So turn a technique into
two or more actions -- the eye flick turning into an elbow strike which
turns into another technique in the opposite direction -- all performed
together. The idea is to condense movement so you can accomplish in one
move what normally would take two, three or four moves. This drastically
speeds things up and allows you to address multiple attackers almost simultaneously.
Let's look at this in more detail. Here, as you withdraw your arm from
the finger flick you turn to the left to face the man on your left. As
you do so, sink backward and down (cat stance) to attack the man on your
movement would normally be exceptionally dangerous since your back is
now facing an attacker, but your right elbow from the same arm that did
the flick can now be used as a weapon striking backwards (into the ribs
or face) to hit the man to your right (now behind you). You can also add
a simultaneous backwards head butt (into the nose or side of the head)
and a foot stomp onto the toes of this same person. -- an quick, powerful
In one continuous motion you have dealt with two opponents and are facing
the third. The same arm that had elbowed could also now proceed forward
into a punch or virtually any technique. This is often referred to as
the "Principle of Continuous Motion," or the "Principle
of Economy of Motion." (1)
moving backward to attack one opponent and sinking into a stance with
the hips pushed backward you have also created a small, momentary space
to your front. In the scenario presented here the next technique is not
done by the arm or hand (thus breaking the continuous motion of the right
arm), but is a front kick into the groin of the third attacker. (2)
You now move in on this attacker, who has bent over in pain, and control/spin
his body into the person who was first in the middle (who you initially
eye flicked). That person is momentarily blocked. You have now dealt with
him twice in a fraction of a second.
In the final photo you have completely turned again to address the man
who had just before elbowed, head butted and stomped on -- his second
visit too. In this illustration the man is still reeling in pain, so he
is easily pulled forward on top of the man already turned and bent over.
attacker is now bent over the second and both are momentarily out of action.
The two block the path of the man who was originally in the middle - his
third visit. You now wait for any further action. (Photo 6)
Although this is a simplified scenario it illustrates important principles
of movement that are useful in tight spaces.
5 - The Wedge
In this situation the lead attacker approaches first and is out front
of other attackers. The attacker can also be standing in front of you
but positioned directly in front of two or three others. While
this is still not a great scenario in the midst of a very bad situation,
at least it gives the defender some advantage up front. In either case
the leader is the only person within reach of you and his position is
also blocking the others.
If the first attacker is in front and separated from the others, this
is an ideal time to try to deal with him quickly (see Part 2, "Severing
The Head Of The Serpent"). If you are successful you might persuade
the others to opt out of the conflict. You can also use his body as a
shield, a barrier or knock him into others to disperse them just like
racked pool balls at the start of a game (Part
2, "Use Your New Friends").
If the attacker is standing directly in front of others, if you don't
immediately defeat him at least push him backwards into the others (see
Part 3, the movement principle of "Bump and Run").
In either case, the disrupted formation of attackers can then be dealt
with. However they are dispersed, use movement to stay on the outside
and to align one in front of another, and move in order to minimize the
number close to you. Limit your exposure. Don't get between them. If you
do break out using the movement strategies illustrated above.
6 - Runners and Chargers
For analysis purposes we first examined a series of possible fixed static
formations and how to use movement to address them. In this sixth section
we "turn the tables" so to speak and discuss various movement
strategies in situations where the opponents are rapidly moving -- towards
A runner is someone who is actually running, but since he is running
his attack is more likely to be a tackle or take down. A charger, however,
is someone who was once lingering outside your reach but who suddenly
moves (charges) towards you and attacks. A runner can turn into a charger.
Discussed below are various strategies to be used in these type of attacks
and how to get past or through them (if there are several persons) so
you aren't overpowered, tackled or taken to the ground. If you are successful
the attacker or attackers will slow, stop, turn and move back towards
you at a slower pace. At this point the situation reverts to the various
strategies discussed above. Here, however, we focus just on the initial
aspect of how not to be overwhelmed by a running or charging attack.
Let's start with a single attacker. The faster someone is approaching,
the more momentum and often the less stability he has. This can be used
to your advantage, but you can't just stand your ground. The strategy
is to wait until the last moment and then quickly move out of the way,
outflank the attackers, pivot and don't be there. The same strategy can
be used against several attackers if they are bunched close together and
is similar to "The Wall" or "Loose Half Circle" discussed
Another alternative against a fast approaching attacker, and one often
used in aikido, is simply to wait until the last moment and then drop
to the ground at the feet of your attacker so he will trip over your body.
When I was teaching karate in Peoria Illinois in the late 1960's, I once
had a student who had played football in college and then was a semi-professional.
In freefighting he was especially adept at one technique similar to this.
He would suddenly explode into your feet, a quick roll that would totally
upend you. It was so fast and so powerful that unless you knew it was
coming, you were totally surprised.
Another strategy against someone running toward you is to move quickly
towards him at a wide looping angle. This cuts the time and distance he
has to react, and forces him to slow down as he tries to change the direction
of his momentum. But don't move too soon. Wait until he is eight or ten
feet away. If you move sooner it is considerably easier for the attacker
If two or three people are all running at you from a distance and they
are a little spread out, you can also react as you would in the "The
Wall" or "Loose Half Circle" examples -- again go to the
outside to outflank the group. Often a pivot added at the end is just
enough to let the outside person's momentum take him past.
If the group is staggered or further spread out so you can't outflank
them to the side, you have to become especially evasive. Don't let them
know what you are doing by moving in a straight line. The strategy is
to work like a punt returner in football, move between a gap in their
formation, or zig one way towards one person out front and zag toward
the gap behind him.
If the attackers rushing you are spread out behind one another, there
is another strategy available.
Mike Hawley was asked this question by a relative of his who worked as
a prison guard after he had experienced this very situation. In aikido
class Mike demonstrated how your don't try to stop the first or second
attacker. You stand relaxed and as each closes in, you open your body
and pivot around to let him pass (often using your outstretched arms to
help) and then deal with the next. Only when you get to the last man do
you deal with him.
The reason is simple. The first one has a lot of momentum and energy
with him and can knock you over or tie you up easily. The others will
just jump on. But if you can get past the first runners, they will take
time to slow and then reverse direction. This gives you time to deal with
the last person first, then the second to last, etc.
In group confrontations defenders also often have to deal with attackers
who charge in. The actual distance moved might be short, but when combined
with an attack it is quite threatening. The strategy is the same as against
runners -- don't be there because if you are, you can be overpowered,
grabbed or taken down. Again the strategy is to turn, move or pivot to
the side of the attacker.
A friend of mine, Sensei Paul Williams, is one of the most powerful and
accomplished freefighting (point and semi-contact) competitors I have
ever known. He is a master at the use of angles, turns and spins. I am
often amused at competitions when I see how he deals with a fast aggressive
attack -- by spinning to the outside or behind. The attacker often looks
stunned, confused at where his target has gone, until notified a split
second later from some angle that Paul is definitely still around. Paul
proves that this type of movement strategy is as effective in one-on-one
situations as it is against multiple opponents.
A simple pivot or turn is easy to demonstrate. In the first photo two
opponents are facing each other. The defender at right, has his right
foot forward. In the next photo, the defender has merely pivoted to the
side on this same foot. It doesn't matter what the attack is, and the
faster the attack is (the more momentum it has) the easier it is to get
to the outside. (3)
A similar technique is to intercept an attack, such as a stomach kick,
with a block that guides the attack past you and allows you to move to
the side of the attacker to counter. In Seido Karate there is a series
of techniques known as Seido Strategy that teaches this movement strategy.
For example, if you are standing left foot forward with your hands in
front of you and an opponent does a left front snap kick, you respond
with a left down block (right hand up protecting your face) as you step
forward (right foot) at an angle to the right. The kick is guided past
and you end up at the exposed side of the kicker, well within range for
counter punches and/or a take down.
If, however, the charging attacker is trying to hit your head with something,
a fast drop to the ground under his feet would also work. But don't stay
there, for other attackers may be approaching.
The next and last article in this series will discuss special situations,
such as going to the ground, of if attackers catch up with you and all
(1) Karate masters have always talked about
how students' techniques progress over time. At first students learn to
first block and then counter (two counts). Later a technique might first
block and then continue on to become a counter (One and one half counts).
Finally, more mastery can result of a single technique being a simultaneous
block and counter (one count). This is another example of this principle.
(2) This sequence is illustrated in Pinan
Two and Four. The defender turns left but sinks back and down into a cat
stance. In both kata the right elbow is pulled back in what the casual
observer assumes is preparation for the technique to come. By using (and
changing slightly) the initial movement that ends up in the elbow being
pulled back, other possible techniques are disguised, such as an initial
technique to the front (here being an eye flick) and an elbow backwards.
The accompanying head and foot technique are natural additions to the
It is a movement strategy to be used when there is otherwise little room
to move as in Pinan #1. Thus, everything is truncated. Two or three attacks
and/or counters are best linked into a single technique. The stance used
here (cat stance) will also create additional space. The movement pattern
is very simple.
In the kata you perform simple techniques starting in the cat stance.
In Pinan #2 there is additional movement to the side. In Pinan #4, there
is not. In each case, however, the movements are closer in and then the
defender turns. And just like in other examples, the attacker just dealt
with can be used to block or interfer with other attackers. The specific
techniques used depend on the situation or the attack involved. In the
scenario above a kick to the groin is shown. A punch or other technique
could be added.
Just as in other examples discussed above, the turning motion has additional
possibilities -- a spin, take down or throw of the opponent --maybe into
the feet or body of the first person attacked, the man initially in front.
(3) This is the same pivot found in Pinan
#1 (at the end of three steps forward). In the kata the practitioner had
been doing upper blocks, but here we are only looking at patterns of movement.
At the end of the last step there is a pivot and turn. In the kata the
practitioner turn to move in another direction, but the turn itself allows
the body to also face the other direction (that of the attacker).
I: Interfering With And Avoiding An Impending Attack
Part 2 Principles & Tactics
3 Maneuvering For Advantage: Basics
4 Maneuvering For Advantage: Putting it all together
Part 5:Maneuvering For Advantage: More Scenarios
About the Author:
Christopher Caile is the Founder and Editor-In-Chief of FightingArts.com.
He has been a student of the martial arts for over 40 years and holds
a 6th degree black belt in Seido Karate and has experience in judo, aikido,
diato-ryu, boxing and several Chinese fighting arts. He is also a long-term
student of one branch of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Qigong. He is a
personal disciple of the qi gong master and teacher of acupuncture Dr.
Zaiwan Shen (M.D., Ph.D.) and is Vice-President of the DS International
Chi Medicine Association. In Buffalo, NY, he founded the Qi gong Healing
Institute and The Qi Medicine Association at the State University of New
York at Buffalo. He has also written on Qi gong and other health topics
in a national magazine, the Holistic Health Journal and had been filmed
for a prospective PBS presentation on Alternative Medicine. Recently he
contributed a chapter on the subject to an award winning book on alternative
medicine, "Resources Guide To Alternative Health" produced
by Health Inform.