Hi Senseiaverywax
This is my opionion.
Ok. If you realy are who you say you are then fine. If you fought during the 2nd world war then fine. The battle of Okinawa was from what I have read horrific. You are not the only person who has had to do as ordered on a battle field to an enemy during time of war so can we get one some things straight please?
Any war is horrific.
This is a karate forum. Not a war forum.
If you as it would seem have some answers to questions then fine.
If you can offer some advise on training then fine.
If you are indeed an ex vet then please stop behaving like an a### h### and talk karate.Your beginning to give ex vets a bad name.
I am not interested in arguing or tit for tat.so would you like to talk karate?

If you would then perhaps let us know your opinions on katas and bunkia?

How they have changed etc?

Thanks

Andy

Ed,

I was on Okinawa in the 1940's not the 50's I no you can read but comprehention seems to be a lttle hazy for you.
Unless you are a bunch of panty waisted Mama's Boys!



Ok how about cutting back on the crap? and


Could you anwer some questions please?

The channans why were they created?

What do you see as correct karate?

How about if you give some moves from channons then the bunkia on here?

If I do the research as you suggest then what?

The truth of the Channan Kata's is this, they do still exist and are taught in some circles. How ever most people who ask Questions about them do not really want to know them as in learn them by being taught by somone who know's them. they would however like for someone to write them down or Video tape them so they can compare the difference but are to lazy to do the work and learn the actual kata themselves.

Cr#p again.
I have never seen them or been shown them. If i were to be shown them then I would like to also be taught the relevent bunkia. If the bunkie is a joke and totaly in practical then I will poss question the kata.

So how about ok the first so many moves with bunkia?