Posted by: zoth13
Need help with Self-Defense - 07/26/06 11:03 AM
Hi all,
Wondering if I could get some advice on my training. First let me say that my goal in taking a martial art is self-defense, not competition or taking an art for art's sake. My sport experience is that I wrestled for five years in middle/ high school. My martial arts experience is: I have two years of Judo training followed by one year of eagle claw kung fu, and currently two years of no-gi submission grappling.
After the first two years of Judo I started to see that it was not a complete art for self-defense. There were no strikes, certain holds were not allowed, no weapon defense, some throws required a gi, no defense against strikes etc. I did however enjoy the randori and found that to be valuable.
So I moved on and tried (under the advice of a friend) eagle claw kung fu. After a year I found this to be too static, no live sparring or randori, strange weapons etc. I began to look for another solution.
Coming from a wrestling background I found a school that teaches no-gi grappling, and I have been training there for two years now. Recently I have found myself coming back to the same problems I had with Judo: no defense against strikes, no weapon defense etc. I like the fact that we randori live every class, and there are no illegal holds. But I don’t feel it is a complete art for self defense.
So I have started checking out new schools and have come the following ideas. I took a few karate classes, which I didn’t really think fit the bill for me. I took an Aikido class which was seemed to lack the randori aspect and was really expensive. I then checked out an Aiki Ju Jutsu School. I enjoyed Aiki Ju Jutsu, and the school I checked out has one hour class of Atemi Jutsu followed by a one hour Aiki Ju Jutsu class. The Ju Jutsu class I took had solid throws, weapon defense and striking defense. The striking class had decent striking to close the gap to clinch which then ended in takedowns. The only thing I didn’t like was the fact that the Aiki Ju Jutsu school didn’t go live at all.
So I went back to my old Judo school and took a few classes. I enjoyed it as before but still the instructors were focused on sport rather than self-defense. So I think a cross training of Judo and Aiki Ju Jutsu may be the way to go. Any advice, ideas, comments would be appreciated.
Thanks
Wondering if I could get some advice on my training. First let me say that my goal in taking a martial art is self-defense, not competition or taking an art for art's sake. My sport experience is that I wrestled for five years in middle/ high school. My martial arts experience is: I have two years of Judo training followed by one year of eagle claw kung fu, and currently two years of no-gi submission grappling.
After the first two years of Judo I started to see that it was not a complete art for self-defense. There were no strikes, certain holds were not allowed, no weapon defense, some throws required a gi, no defense against strikes etc. I did however enjoy the randori and found that to be valuable.
So I moved on and tried (under the advice of a friend) eagle claw kung fu. After a year I found this to be too static, no live sparring or randori, strange weapons etc. I began to look for another solution.
Coming from a wrestling background I found a school that teaches no-gi grappling, and I have been training there for two years now. Recently I have found myself coming back to the same problems I had with Judo: no defense against strikes, no weapon defense etc. I like the fact that we randori live every class, and there are no illegal holds. But I don’t feel it is a complete art for self defense.
So I have started checking out new schools and have come the following ideas. I took a few karate classes, which I didn’t really think fit the bill for me. I took an Aikido class which was seemed to lack the randori aspect and was really expensive. I then checked out an Aiki Ju Jutsu School. I enjoyed Aiki Ju Jutsu, and the school I checked out has one hour class of Atemi Jutsu followed by a one hour Aiki Ju Jutsu class. The Ju Jutsu class I took had solid throws, weapon defense and striking defense. The striking class had decent striking to close the gap to clinch which then ended in takedowns. The only thing I didn’t like was the fact that the Aiki Ju Jutsu school didn’t go live at all.
So I went back to my old Judo school and took a few classes. I enjoyed it as before but still the instructors were focused on sport rather than self-defense. So I think a cross training of Judo and Aiki Ju Jutsu may be the way to go. Any advice, ideas, comments would be appreciated.
Thanks