Low Crime Rate in Japan

Posted by: MiSt

Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/06/09 05:21 PM

Why is it that the crime rate in Japan is so low compared to western countries such as the UK and America?

Obviously its debatable whether the crime rate really IS lower in Japan, but for arguments sake lets go with the general academic consensus that it is.

A lot of you will of course have an 'above average' knowledge of Japanese culture, and will be aware that social solidarity is much higher (the importance of group membership), does this explain the lower crime rate?

or perhaps the Yakuza keep unorganized crime in check?

In this climate of political uncertainty and economic struggle this question is more important than ever before, as Western crime rates can only be expected to rise!

Opinions!
Posted by: JoelM

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/07/09 12:26 AM

Do you have statistics?
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/07/09 03:01 AM

I am aware of the western perception that crime rate is lower in Japan than in the west, but I have no idea as to the validity of that presumption.

Should it hold true, then I would posit a theory that any culture that is based around saving 'face' and maintaining honour, will, by extension, condition its populace to adhere to certain behavioural norms - a stronger sense of 'brothers keeper' if you will, where shame, or avoidance of, becomes a controlling factor in personal choice.

In the west we harp on so much about personal freedom being the ultimate corner-stone of civilisation that we dont acknowledge that all we seem to do is abuse it.

That being said, Victorian Britain had far stauncher rules and social mores , yet 4 in 6 households used opiates, and prostitution and murder were rife.

I await input from those with facts/figures and experience of Japan, with great interest.
Posted by: fileboy2002

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/07/09 05:16 PM

I do not pretend to be an expert on Japanese culture. However, it seems to me a culture preoccupied with saving face and maintaining honor might be just as likely to promote violence as prevent it. Saving face and preserving "honor" are big factors in gang violence here in the US.

I suspect the real key might lie in the fact Japan is (or was until recently) one of the world's most egalitarian societies, at least in terms of income distribution. Yes, Japan has a strong social hierarchy. However, those positioned in high social positions are still bound by strict rules--they cannnot exercise unlimited, arbitrary power over their social inferiors. This might also help preserve social order.
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/07/09 06:29 PM

It's because Japan is racially homogenous.
Posted by: MiSt

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/07/09 07:05 PM

I smell
Posted by: fileboy2002

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/07/09 07:20 PM

Racial homogenieity does not explain it either. Most violent crime occurs WITHIN racial and/or ethnic groups, not between them.
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/07/09 07:55 PM

And you have some statistics to support that?

Ever hear of the Balkans, or the West bank? Violent crime inevitably occurs when disparate peoples are forced into cohabitation. Just like the U.S, and now the U.K.

Japan has fiercely resisted immigration and has always accerted it's right to racial homogenity. And they have so far benefitted from it, i.e. low crime.
Posted by: MiSt

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/07/09 08:34 PM

Drunk flatmate ^ Yes I do just in the process of writing a post.
Posted by: rideonlythelabel

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 12:30 AM

Quote:

And you have some statistics to support that?

Ever hear of the Balkans, or the West bank? Violent crime inevitably occurs when disparate peoples are forced into cohabitation. Just like the U.S, and now the U.K.

Japan has fiercely resisted immigration and has always accerted it's right to racial homogenity. And they have so far benefitted from it, i.e. low crime.




I assume you have statistics to support your point as well. Care to post them?
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 05:46 AM

My brother in law worked in Japan for some years, and did experience some racial hostility aimed at him, but not in the sense of outward hostility or violence, more just a lack of acceptance, and being kept 'outside' of the group with which he was working.

Christy, you cannot put all crime down to racial factors, its a huge over simplification of one small element of criminal activity.

On the point of saving face and honour being a trigger to crime, not a deterrent - its all down to cultural interperetation of those concepts.

In a gang environment, the concept of 'respect' is essentialy about fear. Behaving in a way that deterrs others from challenging or attacking you, and controlling those around you.
In such circumstances, the term 'respect' is used erroneously (sp?).

Now in Japan, the idea of saving face is to behave in such a way as to not bring shame on yourself or your family. This means that should you inadvertantly disrespect someone, your instinct is to make that right, for fear of losing face yourself. i think parallels can be drawn to the rules of ettiquet that existed in 18th and 19th century England.

This parallel can also be seen in the way that entertainment of both these cultures was/is geared towards an escape from such rigid confines.

The English had bawdy houses, freak shows, painted ladies, opium dens, pornography etc, whilst one only has to look at certain elements of japanese anime, manga and cinema to see the material is a reactionary release from the pressure of the societies formality - the Id of a nation repressed, splatted all over the page and the screen.
Posted by: Prizewriter

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 09:36 AM

Another important factor in this (I think) is the "Ie Ie ", or extended family. This is a tradition that still exists in Japan. 3, 4 or even 5 generations of family live under the same roof.

Although many families in Japan are nuclear families (perhaps with a single grandparent living with them) their values come from the Ie tradition.

Children having constant supervision and attention from adults (be it grandparents or parents) may contribute to crime figures in Japan. I would not say this is the main factor in the low crime levels, but I would suggest the family structure, based on Ie traditions, would be a crucial factor that would effect how people act in wider society.

I don't have figures for Ie/nuclear families in Japan, but here is some interesting research on Japanese Familes and culture in video clip format from Havard University professors:

http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/at_japan_soc/
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 03:41 PM

This is an interesting article that might answere the initial question.

http://www.amren.com/mtnews/archives/2008/01/in_praise_of_ho.php
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 03:56 PM

Quote:

This is an interesting article that might answere the initial question.

http://www.amren.com/mtnews/archives/2008/01/in_praise_of_ho.php




Its a redundant piece of xenophobic propaganda.

How can any nation be homogenous? We are all immigrants- hell, the Japanese are immigrants (History for the win).

The answer lies elsewhere, but, as a believer in freedom, I support your right to believe whatever nonsense helps you make sense of your world.
Posted by: MiSt

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 04:26 PM

http://www.csdp.org/research/hosb1203.pdf

Looking at table B page 7/27 we can see that per 100,000 people Japan has significantly less people in prison than any western country.

EU average: 87

USA: 689

Japan: 50


Obviously this is only one indication of crime rate, and only counts those criminals who are caught. Interestingly Japan also has less police.

Table 1, page 8/24 shows the total amount of crimes recorded by police, its important to note however that this table shows TOTAL AMOUNT of recorded crime, so a comparison between say Northern Ireland and Japan would be rather complicated.

Japan's total population is:

127,288,416 (July 2008 est.)

Russia's:

140,702,096 (July 2008 est.)

Total recorded crime in 2001:

Japan: 2 735 612

Russia: 2 968 600

That comparison actually came out much closer than I imagined, I was only looking for a country with a similar population size to that of Japan. However Japan still has a significantly lower crime rate as well as lower population.

The problem with these stats is that the differences in population make it hard for comparison; I' m going to look into finding some clearer statistics because I'm disappointed in what I've found.

Obviously statistics have their faults, only recorded crime is counted and there may be differences in what constitutes as recordable crime between countries and so on, but it’s the best source of information to give an overall picture.
Posted by: rideonlythelabel

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 05:04 PM

Quote:

This is an interesting article that might answere the initial question.

http://www.amren.com/mtnews/archives/2008/01/in_praise_of_ho.php




Let me sum up this article.

Japan has low crime rate, and Japan has high racial homogeneity. I am going to disregard every other variable and claim low crime is the product of high racial homogeneity, because it supports my racist agenda.
Posted by: MiSt

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 05:48 PM

Yes, he interpreted every 'positive' difference he saw to be down to racial homogeneity.
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 06:59 PM

Oh man

Hey 'rideonlythelabel'-

So, uhm.. unflattering facts = racist agenda, huh.
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 07:06 PM

Cord-

That was a pretty rude, but as a fellow believer in freedom I support your right to arrogantly make judgements about people you know nothing about, and assume you know exactly how they see the world.
Posted by: MiSt

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 08:23 PM

"unflattering facts"- It was based upon one indivdual case study, the authors. Thats not fact, its personal experience and two people can experience the same thing and interpritate it enteriely differently. I'm not saying personal experience can't be used to back up ideas, but it should be used along side other sources of information. I will confess, I have been socialised to beleive racism to be wrong, and that article IS racist, and as such it angers me and any emotion doesn't exactly help my 'logical' thinking.
Posted by: JoelM

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 09:12 PM

Quote:

That comparison actually came out much closer than I imagined, I was only looking for a country with a similar population size to that of Japan. However Japan still has a significantly lower crime rate as well as lower population.





So which is it, closer than you thought or significantly lower rate? I don't see how you can say both.


Quote:

The problem with these stats is that the differences in population make it hard for comparison; I' m going to look into finding some clearer statistics because I'm disappointed in what I've found.




Translation- I can't find the data to back up my hypothesis, I must find other data.

Quote:

Obviously statistics have their faults, only recorded crime is counted and there may be differences in what constitutes as recordable crime between countries and so on, but it’s the best source of information to give an overall picture.




Translation- The data is flawed, not my hypothesis.


Did I miss anything?
Posted by: JoelM

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 09:22 PM

http://www.csdp.org/research/hosb1203.pdf


Crimes reported by the police percentage changes

Average annual 1991-2001

Russia 3.2%

Japan 4.8%

USA -2.0%


We win!
Posted by: MiSt

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/08/09 10:58 PM

Quote:

So which is it, closer than you thought or significantly lower rate? I don't see how you can say both.




There’s still a significant difference, just not to the extent I originally thought.

Quote:

Translation- I can't find the data to back up my hypothesis, I must find other data.




The data does back up my hypothesis, but its not enough.

Quote:

Translation- The data is flawed, not my hypothesis.




That’s not what I'm saying - merely acknowledging the weakness of the data. It could go both ways, for example underreported crime in the USA and over reported crime in Japan.

The stats you point out are changes, not overall figures, so yes reported crime to the police in the USA might have gone down, but it may still be much higher than elsewhere overall.
Posted by: rideonlythelabel

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 01:45 AM

Quote:

Oh man

Hey 'rideonlythelabel'-

So, uhm.. unflattering facts = racist agenda, huh.




Do you actually believe that this website is not racist?

You're trolling, right?
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 05:25 AM

Quote:

Cord-

That was a pretty rude, but as a fellow believer in freedom I support your right to arrogantly make judgements about people you know nothing about, and assume you know exactly how they see the world.




No, I will tell you what is 'rude' - offering as fact a pile of dross that confidently asserts that black and hispanic races carry ou their work with less professionalism and a worse attitude than other races.

WTF!!!???

yeah, those slovenly no-good wetbacks like Oscar De La Hoya, Roberto Duran, Salma Hayek, J-Lo etc,

and as for those of african descent, why, only the other day I recieved an email from Razorfoot, and having read it, I found that my MP3 collection had been ripped!!!


Give me a f*cking break.

Any article that removes the identity of the individual, and judges on prejudice, is academicaly, morally, and spiritualy, redundant.

There is an old theory that says any internet argument, when emotive enough, will evolve to a point where Hitler can/will be mentioned.

Sometimes, this is tenuous at best, other times downright ridiculous, but with today's global financial climate echoing the collapse of the 20's and 30's, there are certain parallels, and it is in such times that people are only too happy to have a scapegoat, or a target for their misery/anger.

Hitler gave his people Jews and Romanies as sources of all problems.

This report gives diversity, citing african-american and south american cultures as principle 'villains'.

As the world is mixed and diverse, and things cannot be magically reversed, what do you suggest Christy? How many will have their lives ruined/destroyed in your quest for utopia??

If thats what it takes to make it happen, you can stick your utopia up your fascist arse.

Come to think of it Christy, unless you are Native American Indian, where should they deport you?
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 05:54 AM

http://money.aol.co.uk/japan-posts-record-deficit/article/2009030901411657021379

Damn pesky immigrants must have got in somehow eh?

Actually, this brings into focus a point as yet touched upon, and that is that Japan is a very affluent country, and taking into account the ethos of looking after family, the majority want for little.
There is no doubt that poverty and deprivation influences crime rate, and so it will be interesting to see what happens to Japan's crime rate as the global recession bites into their, predominantly homogenous, society.
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 04:02 PM

Cord-

Are you finished? Is it cold, way up there on your high horse?

So your comparing me to Hitler, huh? Because an article that I posted, suggests that in the U.S at least, blacks and hispanics make up numerically less than white population but account for the statistical majority of violent crime. This is FACT. And pointing it out makes me a racist?! I would get angry, but since YOU have obviously never lived in a black ghetto or hispanic barrio here in the U.S., I'll just take your politically-correct thuggery as the rantings of a well intentioned but terribly sheltered fool.

Question. Were you raised the son of two white policemen in a black ghetto on the east side of Detroit in the 80's and 90's? You see, I was. I know damn well what I'm talking about when talk about crime and ethinicity. I was not socialized to be racist either; I grew up Catholic.

You liberal thugs are so quick to yell "RACIST!" at anyone who says something you don't agree with, that the word has lost all meaning by now. It's little more than a childs' taunt at this point. Find some new material, pal.
Posted by: MattJ

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 04:16 PM

Cord has called you correctly, Christy. You ARE a racist. Your source, from Google:

"American Renaissance -

A conservative monthly publication. Promotes a variety of white racial positions.
www.amren.com/ - 55k - Cached - Similar pages"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Renaissance_(magazine)
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 04:57 PM

Quote:

Cord-

Are you finished?




Not even close.

Quote:

Is it cold, way up there on your high horse?




living in a world where you open your mind to every colour and creed being allowed to be your friend is a warm and happy climate.

Quote:

So your comparing me to Hitler, huh?




Hitler posited that the majority of Germany's ills, both social and economic, could be laid at the doorstep of two specific racial groups within his society. he believed that eradicating/removing them from that society would strengthen it.

Sound familiar herr Christy?

Quote:

Because an article that I posted, suggests that in the U.S at least, blacks and hispanics make up numerically less than white population but account for the statistical majority of violent crime. This is FACT.




And is that violent crime directed directly at other races? Are the Crips and bloods clearly devided between racial groups? Does much of the crime happen in 'ghetto's' where the polution is largely of a single extraction?

Again, this is a socio-economic issue, not a racial one. The fact that certain racial heritages make up the larger part of the 'have nots' in your country compared to 'WASPS' is an issue for your society as a whole to heal.

Quote:

And pointing it out makes me a racist?!




No, taking the decision to judge all individuals by their race, not their merits as people, makes you a racist.

Quote:

I would get angry, but since YOU have obviously never lived in a black ghetto or hispanic barrio here in the U.S., I'll just take your politically-correct thuggery as the rantings of a well intentioned but terribly sheltered fool.




Grumbleweed (a member on here), recently visited a friend of his in South Central for a holiday- he got taken round house parties, went for his morning run, went drinking and having a rare old time.

I hope he wont mind me saying this, but Grumbleweed is not exactly an imposing guy - he has a 'normal' haircut, he has thick glasses, is fit, but not big, and does not give off 'dont f*ck with me' signals in any way.
What he does give signals of, is being a really nice guy, who has travelled the world, lived in many different cultures, and approaches ever individual with a friendly open mind.

Imagine that eh? scrawny white bread running around the hood with no trouble whatsoever.

I wonder why?

Quote:

Question. Were you raised the son of two white policemen in a black ghetto on the east side of Detroit in the 80's and 90's? You see, I was. I know damn well what I'm talking about when talk about crime and ethinicity.




Nope, I was raised a white son of a retired policeman who had spent 25 years working in a foreign culture (Hong Kong), who could talk Cantonese and Mandarin, and encouraged me to travel and relish different cultures.

Experiences vary- but your experiences are no more global than mine, and judging what is right in Japan based on what you decided was wrong in Detroit 20 years ago makes you a fool.

Quote:

I was not socialized to be racist either; I grew up Catholic.




great, so you can be a bigot, and get forgiven for it. Whats the going exchange rate on ethnic cleansing these days- 200 hail mary's? more?

Quote:

You liberal thugs are so quick to yell "RACIST!" at anyone who says something you don't agree with, that the word has lost all meaning by now. It's little more than a childs' taunt at this point. Find some new material, pal.




1. I am, in no way, a liberal. I am an individualist.
2. I am, in no way, your pal.
3. If it meant nothing to you, you would not respond. Kid yourself you dont care, one day, you might mean it.

Let me ask you this: Do you think Barrack Obama will work with less determination, or with less professionalism than Bush?
If a black cop responded to your 911 call, would you presume them to be inept?
If you walked down a street and had to pass through a group of white youths wearing hoods, would you feel more at ease than walking through a similar group of coloured youths?

You see, if the answer to the President/Cop question is 'No', then you dont actually agree with the article you are defending, you are merely responding to a powerful, simple rhetoric that allows you to feel you have a handle on social issues.

If the answer to the white/black youths question is 'yes' then you are an idiot - you should be equally as wary of both groups, and their intentions.

If the answer to all 3 is 'yes' then you should just man up and accept that you are racist. Pal.
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 05:00 PM

Oh wow! It's MattJ again! Been awhile, huh?

RACIST (According to MattJ and Cord) : Anyone who says anything that is even remotely less than absolutely sparkling about anyone who isn't white. Anyone who uses statistical facts to back up such statements. Also appropriate for victims of black-on-white crime, republicans, and just about anyone who MattJ and Cord just don't agree with in general.

Seriously Matt, you haven't got sh1t on me, and we both know it. So call me 'racist' or whatever else you like until your throat is sore and your fingertips are blistered. Whatever makes you feel better about yourself. Then take a deep breath, and go get some therapy. Peeeeace.
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 05:03 PM

Care to answer any of the questions asked of you, or are you just going to blow hot air out of your arse and hope we think its smells like roses?
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 05:10 PM

Cord-

My father and your father have something in common then. Mine was at two-time Vietnam veteran as a chopper pilot, he speaks fluent Vietnamese, and encouraged me to learn foreign languages as well.

I think there is a big difference between the exciting little weekend adventue in "the hood" that your friend had, and actually BEING RAISED THERE. But you seem quite sheltered, so I won't waste my breath.

You know, the more you call me a bigot and racist, the more I think that it is actually you that is dealing with some issues. Sheesh, why else are getting so worked up?

P.S. - I have plenty of friends, I don't need a 'pal' but thanks for clarifying.
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 05:27 PM

Quote:

Cord-

My father and your father have something in common then. Mine was at two-time Vietnam veteran as a chopper pilot, he speaks fluent Vietnamese, and encouraged me to learn foreign languages as well.




My dad is a WWII vet.

Quote:

I think there is a big difference between the exciting little weekend adventue in "the hood" that your friend had, and actually BEING RAISED THERE.




Yep - less local knowledge, fewer people to vouch for or help him in the two weeks he spent being hosted by his black friend, that he met in Thailand, and who invited him over to meet his friends in his neighbourhood. Sounds awful

Quote:

But you seem quite sheltered, so I won't waste my breath.




oh sweetheart, I had seen the pyramids by the age of 12, I have stood at the wailing wall, and walked the path Jesus allegedly took to Golgotha. I have travelled around Europe, and visited your country on 3 occasions as well.

i see things globally, while your brain processes things through one area of detroit.

Now that is sheltered.

Answer the questions, if you have the courage.

Quote:

You know, the more you call me a bigot and racist, the more I think that it is actually you that is dealing with some issues.




I have taken issue with your assertion that bigotry is the answer to the worlds problems. Nothing more. Or less.

Quote:

Sheesh, why else are getting so worked up?




Because I have black friends. Because I have asian friends. Because the family who run our local convenience store, a good, happy, friendly muslim family, who give us gifts at christmas and will do anything they can to help if you need it, get assaulted, insulted, and looked at ascance by a$$holes like you.

Quote:

P.S. - I have plenty of friends, I don't need a 'pal' but thanks for clarifying.




And a healthy bunch of middle class white people I am sure they are too. Would you let any of them hold your winning lottery ticket while you went to the can though?
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 05:36 PM

So you could afford things that my family couldn't. Profuse apologies. Listen, you don't know anything about me, and you're attacks are becoming increasingly personal, and I haven't done anything to provoke it; I only disagreed with you. I'm going to back off now, because this is starting to make you look like a bully with too much time on your hands. Cheers to the rainbow country!
Posted by: MattJ

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 05:41 PM

Quote:

Oh wow! It's MattJ again! Been awhile, huh?




I'm never far, my little racially-addled friend. *sound of angel's wings*

Quote:

RACIST (According to MattJ and Cord) : Anyone who says anything that is even remotely less than absolutely sparkling about anyone who isn't white. Anyone who uses statistical facts to back up such statements. Also appropriate for victims of black-on-white crime, republicans, and just about anyone who MattJ and Cord just don't agree with in general.




Nice try. But let's go with this, instead:

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/racist

I think these are much more accurate, but I'm sure you will disagree.

Quote:

Seriously Matt, you haven't got sh1t on me, and we both know it.




No? How about this:

http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/glance/jailrace.htm

Quote:

So call me 'racist' or whatever else you like until your throat is sore and your fingertips are blistered. Whatever makes you feel better about yourself. Then take a deep breath, and go get some therapy. Peeeeace.




Or maybe I will tell you to rotate. BTW, I grew up in Baltimore city, one block away from Morgan State university - in the 1970's. My dad was a probation officer in Washington DC - and a WW2 vet. Your upbringing does not entitle you to be an ignorant racist.

You have nothing on ME, jackass.

PS - What is it with you, with all your BS "self-reliance", that you are so quick to point the finger at anyone different? Quit whining.

And Me? Feel free to think of me as a tutu wearing, tree-hugging, granola-crunching, supporter of animal-voting rights that just BLEW YOUR ARGUMENT ALL TO HELL.

Have a nice night.

XXX OOO
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 05:43 PM

Quote:

Answer the questions, if you have the courage.




Thats a 'no' then.

Quote:

So you could afford things that my family couldn't




Everyone can afford an individual the decency of judging them on merit, not race.

Ignorance costs you more than any bank can provide.

Good idea to quit while you are behind btw.
Posted by: MiSt

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 05:47 PM

Quote:

So your comparing me to Hitler, huh? Because an article that I posted, suggests that in the U.S at least, blacks and hispanics make up numerically less than white population but account for the statistical majority of violent crime. This is FACT.




Yup, correct. But its not because they are black, there is a fundamental difference. Simply removing them from the country would not remove the problem, crime is more prevalent around the poor, and none-whites are more likely to be poor. Like Cord said it’s down to socio-economic problems and you’re over simplifying things, there are numerous reasons why none-whites commit more crime, in the USA. In other countries where white is not the native colour whites commit more crime. Locals always look for a scapegoat and who easier than immigrants? In till of course the immigrants become so integrated into society that they become the locals, such as say, the white American?
Posted by: Dereck

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 06:04 PM

WOW. This thread has a life of itself. I definitely don't want to get into this but thought I'd comment on this post.

Quote:

http://www.csdp.org/research/hosb1203.pdf

Looking at table B page 7/27 we can see that per 100,000 people Japan has significantly less people in prison than any western country.

EU average: 87

USA: 689

Japan: 50


Obviously this is only one indication of crime rate, and only counts those criminals who are caught. Interestingly Japan also has less police.




2 years ago when talking a Police course at the main branch down town Edmonton, I learned many interesting things. One issue pertains to this and the comment I've highlighted.

In Churchill Square they was at one time 4+ regular Police Officers patrolling this area that was a high crime area. Because of cut backs all Police Officers were pulled and 2 Security Officers were commissioned to this area. The Edmonton Council had the gall to report their was a decline in crimes committed in this area due to their measures taken. This was the biggest load of $hit to come out of their mouths. In fact the crime rate increased but because only 2 Security Officers were patrolling this area they could not catch as many criminals as the 4+ Police Officers. In fact not having the same training and connections and experience as the Police Officers, the Security Officers were grossly undermanned and educated to deal with this. That the Edmonton council would even dare use these statistics is appalling. This just proves also that statistics can mean crap!

I think this is the case here as well and definitely plays a factor. If Japan has less police then they have less ability to cover all of the crimes let alone apprehend and imprison those offenders.

My personal opinion over some of this thread. In the US and in Canada we have more freedoms then most countries. We act more as individuals then as a society such as Japan and others. We may have even more lax laws letting our offenders get off easier. And we already know we have over populated prisons so the release of offenders on the bottom of the list is very common. Because of all of this we WILL have more crime then other countries. Until we have more prison, stricter laws, fear and making people accountable, our crime will continue to increase. I am already seeing it here and growing.
Posted by: fileboy2002

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 06:39 PM

There are statistics aplenty to support that. If you want to see some, start out by looking at the FBI's annual Uniform Crime Report. You'll see I'm right.

As for the Balkans, Palestine, et al: sure, some conflicts occur between groups. These can break down along ethnic lines (Rwanda), religious lines (Northern Ireland) or both (the Balkans). However, the orginal post refered to violent crime, not civil conflicts, which are an entirely different matter.

That said, your belief that having diverse groups of people living together automatically creates conflict is just flat out wrong. The US is a good example. So is the UK. For all their ethnic and racial diversity, the populations of these two countries get along without bloodshed most of the time. So do people in multiracial countries like France, Germany and Canada. The examples are endless.

Diversity does not lead to conflict; injustice and inequality do. Even when conflicts break down along racial or ethnic lines, they usually have roots in social and/or economic injustice. The LA riots of 1992 broke out over the larger issue of police brutality; Rodney King's beating was only the spark. The Israel/Palestine conflict is ultimately over land. In the Balkans, extreme nationalists and ex-Stalinist thugs stirred up ethnic fears and hatreds in order to preserve their own power amid the collapse of Soviet power.

The bottom line: conflicts happen for a REASON, not just because people are different.
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 07:06 PM

OK.

Fileboy, MiSt, Matt, Cord, I'll tell you what. Houses in Detroit are going for as little as $75.00 USD. Move in here, enroll your kids in the public school system, and then after 2 weeks, no make that 2 days, come up to me and spout all this crap about how racial differences have little or nothing to do with crime. Otherwise, kindly shove it.
Posted by: fileboy2002

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 07:24 PM

Christy, Detroit is a black majority city. Yes, most of the criminals in Detroit are black. However, so are the vast majority if crime victims. What does Detroit prove about interracial conflict?

In any case, I don't have to go to Detroit. I have lived my whole life in the Rogers Park neighborhood of Chicago, which is 1/3 black (also 1/3 white and 1/3 Mexican). So far, I am still here.

What killed Detroit was the collapse of the auto industry, a slow unraveling that began in the 1970s and continues today. Detriot's population has plunged in over the past generation as anyone able to leave left. The only ones left in Detriot are the poor--any wonder the city has a high crime rate?
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 07:34 PM

What killed Detroit was BLACK riots, Coleman Young, busing, the dismantling of undercover police units, and affirmative action. There were a few unfortunate whites still in the city up through 1999 -- they were city employees like policemen and firemen who were contractually obligated to live in the city. My family was one of these. But thanks for the history lesson.
Posted by: MattJ

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 08:04 PM

Quote:

Fileboy, MiSt, Matt, Cord, I'll tell you what. Houses in Detroit are going for as little as $75.00 USD. Move in here, enroll your kids in the public school system, and then after 2 weeks, no make that 2 days, come up to me and spout all this crap about how racial differences have little or nothing to do with crime. Otherwise, kindly shove it.




Bro, again, you have nothing. I grew up in a majority black area - in the 70's, a *far less* enlightened period than what we have now. The problems you have in Detroit are economic, not racial. BTW, I could have decided to live in a majority-white, but economically poorer area, closer to my job. The higher crime rate there convinced me to move elsewhere. Economics, not race, is the major motivator for crime.

Quote:

What killed Detroit was BLACK riots, Coleman Young, busing,




Yes, and WHY were black people rioting? Certainly nothing to do with prevailing social injustices of the time, huh?

Quote:

the dismantling of undercover police units, and affirmative action.




If you mean the dismantling of out-dated racially motivated undercover units, then good riddance. And affirmative action has been a huge boon to this country, fostering the development of a larger, better educated and more affluent middle class. Until the last administration, that is.

Diversity is the great strength, not the weakness, of countries like the US, the UK, Canada, etc. Luckily, the vast majority of people recognize this fact, and ignorant, insecure fools like yourself are the ones standing out (non-homogenous).
Posted by: Ames

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 08:10 PM

Quote:

What killed Detroit was years of racial inequality between Whites and Blacks...




Fixed that for you.

--Chris
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/09/09 08:52 PM

I seriously doubt your area was anything like mine, Mr. Baltimore. But I'll play along. Why were black people rioting? Because an ILLEGAL after hours establishment was raided. They were breaking the law, and got caught. Period. Their actions after that are THEIR own responsibilty, and don't you dare try and justify that kind of lawlessness with some sh1t like "they were treated bad by the police", or some other apologist horsesh1t. Please. As if they were the only one's who were ever given a hard time by a cop.

Those out-dated racially motivated undercover units you mention, yes, had a few a$$holes, but their presence made it safe to take the bus, walk to the store, or church, or school, without becoming a statistic.

So you support affirmative action, huh? Not surprised. I mean after all, you've been passed over for promotions, or denied enrollment in universities because you're white, and you're still cool with it. Hat's off.

This is about the umteenth time you've called me names simply for having a different opinion. So listen, you sad little self-loathing PUNK, if you want to continue throwing insults, just PM me and I'll send you a bus ticket and we can do it in person. Obnoxious coward.
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/10/09 02:44 AM

Quote:

Let me ask you this: Do you think Barrack Obama will work with less determination, or with less professionalism than Bush?

If a black cop responded to your 911 call, would you presume them to be inept?

If you walked down a street and had to pass through a group of white youths wearing hoods, would you feel more at ease than walking through a similar group of coloured youths?





remember these? Answer the questions if you dare. What are you more afraid of - that your answers will portray you in a bad light? or that your honest answers will show that you have conflict within yourself?

As for Detroit, that was the famous vehicle producer was it not? Then the industry collapsed and the society crumbled.

A very similar thing happened in South Wales, (I am Welsh - you think you grew up in a deprived area ), when the Mines closed. And we are not just talking about a negative impact on communities, the communities only existed because of the mines. There was literaly, nothing else in way of employment. After that, drug use, violent crime and suicide rates are all increased much higher in these areas than even some big cities. And you want to talk about racial exclusivity!!! These guys are so South Walian, that you can get a hard time for being north walian when you visit. Lets just say that the only people of colour that they ever knew of were the lads covered in coal dust leaving the colliery at the end of the shift.
Then the WDA and the government enticed massive investment in the region from Japan (Honda in particular). The economy picked up, and guess what? Thats right, social problems reduced. All without any change to the racial diversity of the area. Explain that through your deetroyt eyes.

Did you just offer Matt a violent encounter!? Not very 'white' of you is it? Are you sure your not an immigrant? oh hang on, of course you are, you're a white American.

On the point of the 'undercover' police you cite as being so important - i presume at least some of them would have been black? not much point in them if they stuck out like a sore thumb in your neighbourhood huh? Imagine that? You, valuing the contribution to society of an african-american.

Quote:

Those out-dated racially motivated undercover units you mention, yes, had a few a$$holes




You see, any group of people has a few a-holes. In this instance, you are able to distinguish bad apples, and continue to have confidence in the collective in question.

The same reasoning should be used for MMAers, TMAers, firecrew, paramedics, work colleagues, black people, white people, hispanic people, Asian people, Arabic people

EVERY RACE OF PEOPLE!!!!!

We are not our colour - you do not obey the law because you are white, I would not break the law if I had been born a different race, but had the same upbringing.

To use the lottery ticket analogy, i bet there are some of your friends that are more trutworthy than others. Do you think that those who do not have your full confidence have racial diversity somewhere in their family? Or do you just think they are human and as such, prone to the vices and mental frailties that we as a species have in our make-up?

You see, racism is a self fuelling thing. You decide you dislike people of other ethnicity, and it shows in your interactions with them as individuals. They then may behave unpleasantly to you in return, and you come away thinking they did it because of their race, when actually its because you have been a douche.

You can see that in you on this thread - 'I have done/said nothing to provoke your hostility' - yes you have. You insulted me, before I insulted you. My rudeness was aimed at the article, you came back with a personal insult and took it from there.

Ever consider that you getting grief growing up was not racialy motivated, but because you were just kind of unpleasant?
Posted by: grumbleweed

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/10/09 06:22 AM

Low Crime Rate in Japan

<<It's because Japan is racially homogenous.>>

Thailand (i.e. not a western model of social decay you cite) too has a homogenous society by and large, and 96% buddhist with small pockets of islam and others. The immigration policy is extremely strict and convoluted and simply there is very little racial diversity, yes you have issan/lao people in the north east and khmer speaking people near cambodia and the chinese/thais. That all said, the violent crime rate in Thailand is astronomical and do you know why?….its nothing to do with illegal/legal immigration (well you have lots of petty British gangsters in Pattaya who moved there from the Costas of Spain who up the crime rate there!) its because of social inequalities, I stayed in Thailand for a year and four months of that was in a Bangkok slum with my inlaws and my wife surrounded by grinding poverty (and social ills such as murder, robbery, rape etc) on a scale that makes any US ghetto look like Cape Cod and in spitting distance you were among the hiso wealthy elite class of Bangkok and they are no more or less thai than those in the slums. It comes down to inequalities of ‘the system’ and the ineptitude of the government to address these monumental problems and until they do nothing will change.

Lets look at Malaysia like Japan, in Asia. They have a diverse population, Indians, Chinese, indigenous Malays. Buddhist temples next door to a hindu temple next to a church next to a mosque and from what I saw and have read there is social harmony there by and large ever since the SAS put out the communist threat in the 50’s of course.
Singapore is also a beacon of racial diversity and is as prosperous as Japan with a low crime rate I think.

Its all to easy to rant a rave and finger wag at immigrants and support thugs like the BNP or some WASP group.
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/10/09 07:32 AM

Cheers Grumbleweed, hope you dont mind me taking your name in vain on this thread, its just i know that you have experience of living in other cultures, so your experiences seemed relevant.

Thanks for contributing 1st hand, its appreciated.
Posted by: MattJ

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/10/09 08:19 AM

Quote:

I seriously doubt your area was anything like mine, Mr. Baltimore. But I'll play along.




Ah, I see. YOUR rioting was worse than mine - it's a fine, rational argument you make there.

Quote:

Why were black people rioting? Because an ILLEGAL after hours establishment was raided. They were breaking the law, and got caught. Period.




Yes, PERIOD! All that racial and economic inequity had NOTHING to do with it. Certainly the LAW (and it's attendant undercover units) weren't TARGETING black people unfairly. Gosh, no.

Quote:

Their actions after that are THEIR own responsibilty,




It is? So we're back on the personal responsibility thing again? But weren't you complaining here:

Quote:

So you support affirmative action, huh? Not surprised. I mean after all, you've been passed over for promotions, or denied enrollment in universities because you're white, and you're still cool with it. Hat's off.




So what happened to your vaunted personal responsibility now? You asked have I ever been passed over for promotion at work. Hell no. You know why? Because I don't whine like a pu$$y about other groups trying to take my job - I simply do it better, to the point that NO ONE - white, black or otherwise - passes over me. How's that for personal responsibility?

Quote:

and don't you dare try and justify that kind of lawlessness with some sh1t like "they were treated bad by the police", or some other apologist horsesh1t. Please. As if they were the only one's who were ever given a hard time by a cop.




How about 400 years of mistreatment by most of western society. You are typically short-sighted.

Quote:

Those out-dated racially motivated undercover units you mention, yes, had a few a$$holes, but their presence made it safe to take the bus, walk to the store, or church, or school, without becoming a statistic.




Safer for white people, you mean. That was part of the issue. This is simply not sinking in with you, is it?

Quote:

This is about the umteenth time you've called me names simply for having a different opinion.




Actually, I was attacking your ignorant racism.

Quote:

So listen, you sad little self-loathing PUNK, if you want to continue throwing insults, just PM me and I'll send you a bus ticket and we can do it in person. Obnoxious coward.






Yes, and it's wrong for me to call you names.

OK, OK......I'll save you the bus fare, and give you the breakdown of how it would go:

* We square off, you try to hit or grab me.

* I take you down, put you in a submission, you tap.

* The end.

Should that not suffice, send a ticket here:

http://www.flinchbaughbuslineinc.com/

My name is Matt Jansson.

Have a nice day.
Posted by: grumbleweed

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/10/09 08:52 AM

no problem , however, i do need to talk to you about the 'scrawny' thing, wirey or lean would have been sufficient
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/10/09 09:08 AM

Quote:

My name is Matt Jansson.




i understand - when challenged, a member of FA club has a name. His name is Matt Jansson.

His name is Matt Jansson!?

*all* HIS NAME IS MATT JANSSON. HIS NAME IS MATT JANSSON. HIS NAME IS MATT JANSSON.......
Posted by: Christy

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/10/09 04:04 PM

Cord-

Answeres to your questions, because you're so obsessed with me:

1. Don't know. It's hard to say how much someone could damage a car that someone else has already totalled. I am very confident that Obama will only make matters worse. As far as proffessionalism goes, Bush swaggered across a flight deck like buffoon, but Obama jaw-jacks with idiots at basketball games. I guess they're about equal. I have know idea how to guage a president's determination; only they themselves can know that.

2. Trust me, Detroit has PLENTY of inept black cops. But no, I don't make presumptions based on skin color, believe it or not. You sure like to presume that you know everything about people who are any bit different from you, though.

3. Absolutley yes. And based off personal experience. So make of that whatever you will. What are you going to do now? Give me some title like "Xenophobic Bigot" or "KKK dragon" or whatever it's called? Go ahead. Shows how small you really are. You can't even disagree with someone without resorting to personal attacks or name-calling, all of which on this thread, YOU initiated. And you call me "ignorant". You're quite a piece of work, so good luck with yourself.
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/10/09 05:13 PM

Quote:

1. Don't know. It's hard to say how much someone could damage a car that someone else has already totalled. I am very confident that Obama will only make matters worse. As far as proffessionalism goes, Bush swaggered across a flight deck like buffoon, but Obama jaw-jacks with idiots at basketball games. I guess they're about equal




Do you believe Obama will make things worse because of his politics, or by virtue of his ethnicity? Remember, you are the one who says you are not racist.

Quote:

Trust me, Detroit has PLENTY of inept black cops. But no, I don't make presumptions based on skin color, believe it or not. You sure like to presume that you know everything about people who are any bit different from you, though.




Are they inept because of their colour? Or are they ' a few a-holes' as you acknowledge exist in the white element of the police force?
As for me presuming to know everything about people who are different from me, well, I am not the one making blanket statements about what influences Japan, having never been outside of Detroit by the sounds of it.

Quote:

3. Absolutley yes. And based off personal experience. So make of that whatever you will. What are you going to do now? Give me some title like "Xenophobic Bigot" or "KKK dragon" or whatever it's called? Go ahead. Shows how small you really are




Well, that just goes to show you have never been to the UK - we have equality on our criminals, and that gang of white kids is every bit as likely to kerb stomp you- maybe your home turf isnt that rough after all if the thugs are so easily recognised. Sounds quite nice.
As for being small, well there is always someone bigger in life, mentaly, physicaly, and spritualy. If i am a minnow, then my god, you must be desperately unhappy with where you are on the food chain. But then, that fits nicely with your outlook- bigotry often comes from low self esteem, ignorance and a persecution/victim complex. All of which you have shown through this thread. Your hour on the couch is up herr Christy, pay at reception on your way out

Quote:

You can't even disagree with someone without resorting to personal attacks or name-calling, all of which on this thread, YOU initiated. And you call me "ignorant". You're quite a piece of work, so good luck with yourself.




oh dear, you dont even read do you? My opening to you was that I supported your right to believe a load of unbalanced, academicaly redundant nonsense written by someone else. Thats not a personal insult, that is an insult to the work of a third party.
You then came back calling me arrogant and blah blah blah

That was the start of the personal hostility on this thread. Everything else has been watching you spiral from ignorant to confused, to contradictory, to crying 'bully' (boo hoo), to what I dont know. You have avoided answering points made in posts, choosing to insult and name call, whilst any challenge your ideals have met have been direct responses to stuff you have written. Verbal aikido only works on a complicit Uke, and I aint one to go with the flow baby.

Come back when you have actually travelled outside of Detroit and lost the chip on your shoulder from your childhood, and maybe , just maybe, you will talk some sense.

As it is, you are in a prison of your own construction.
Posted by: Cord

Re: Low Crime Rate in Japan - 03/10/09 05:15 PM

seeing as how you will not answer anything above directly anyway, and as the topic has long since gone off track, Its on lockdown.