martial arts instruction

Posted by: thirdeye

martial arts instruction - 06/28/05 03:43 PM

Being a martial arts beginner, i really want to leard tae kwon
do. I have had one video which was real [censored]. I have tried a tai chi workout video, found it good but not demanding enough.
I live too far away to go to any classes and was hoping if anyone knew about any good tae kwon do dvds? I would be open to suggestion also as i don't know much about martial arts

Posted by: Zombie Zero

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/28/05 04:34 PM

Sorry, thirdeye, but watching a video isn't such a great way to learn martial arts.

A DVD can't watch you perform the techniques, and correct your errors. You can't spar with a VCR.

No feedback = no learning.

Posted by: thirdeye

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/28/05 05:00 PM

Cant say im not dissapointed. Looks like im well and trully stuck. I just find all that keep fit crap too dull. I really need something more involving. I really don't know where to go from now :\

Posted by: Rayman452

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/28/05 07:12 PM

Quote:

Sorry, thirdeye, but watching a video isn't such a great way to learn martial arts.

A DVD can't watch you perform the techniques, and correct your errors. You can't spar with a VCR.

No feedback = no learning.

HAHA, sparring with a VCR. However, if he's using a DVD to learn, wouldn't you spar against a DVD player?

Posted by: Leo_E_49

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/29/05 02:23 AM

Quote:

Cant say im not dissapointed. Looks like im well and trully stuck. I just find all that keep fit crap too dull. I really need something more involving. I really don't know where to go from now :\

What city do you live in? Many people here can refer you to Dojos in your area which you may not hear about without a connection to MA.

Also, check the yellow pages for Martial Arts and search on google for schools in your area. You might not have TKD (unlikely because TKD is one of the most widespread arts in the world) but if there's no TKD but there are other arts, perhaps you should give them a try. In fact, even if there is TKD, give the other arts a try because you will be happiest in an art which suits you. Usually schools have a free trial lesson so you can see whether you want to continue at the school.

Have a look at these:
http://www.thehealthzone.co.uk/martial_arts_uk/martial_art_schools_uk/aberdeen.htm
http://www.aberdeenshire.gov.uk/clubs/detail.asp?keyOrganisation=825
http://www.ukwhatsonguide.co.uk/SCOTMartialArts.htm
http://www.matren.co.uk/art-craft/aberdeenshire.htm
http://www.touchlocal.com/business/search/typeId/1253/type/Martial+Arts,+Clubs+&+Schools/page/10
http://www.amag.org.uk/
http://www.abdn.ac.uk/~aus050/articles/namestyle.php
http://www.google.com.sg/search?biw=1003&hl=en&q=aberdeenshire+martial+arts&meta=

Hope that helps.

Posted by: thirdeye

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/29/05 06:07 AM

Thx for your help with those links have checked them out, but its just too difficult with bus travel and work. I guess my only chance is a fitness club, which would be more flexible for me but i really dont think that is my thing :\

Posted by: JohnL

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/29/05 08:57 AM

Stirling is just down the road from you.

Get there and find somewhere to train.

Posted by: Leo_E_49

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/29/05 10:23 AM

Quote:

Thx for your help with those links have checked them out, but its just too difficult with bus travel and work. I guess my only chance is a fitness club, which would be more flexible for me but i really dont think that is my thing :\

With that attitude, it's no wonder you aren't studying MA. It's your decision but imho, your attitude is the only thing really standing between you and training.

And no, a fitness club won't teach you anything like an MA school. You'll get fit but you won't learn a thing about unarmed combat or the philosophies behind the arts.

Posted by: thirdeye

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/29/05 10:46 AM

Quote:

Quote:

Thx for your help with those links have checked them out, but its just too difficult with bus travel and work. I guess my only chance is a fitness club, which would be more flexible for me but i really dont think that is my thing :\

With that attitude, it's no wonder you aren't studying MA. It's your decision but imho, your attitude is the only thing really standing between you and training.

And no, a fitness club won't teach you anything like an MA school. You'll get fit but you won't learn a thing about unarmed combat or the philosophies behind the arts.

Attitude? Why Can't you see that it's not within my means to
consider this option? the crap bus service and working must be my fault also.

Posted by: Leo_E_49

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/29/05 11:25 AM

Working, of course takes priority. However, most MA are trained after work hours, for obvious reasons. If the busses are crap, leave as early as possible. I'm sure you don't work on Sundays, perhaps you'd like to spend some of your time off work doing some exercise which will benefit you in other ways too, if there's a school open on Sundays (you'd be surprised at the odd times Dojos open).

I can't imagine that there are no schools in that list which have times which won't coincide with your schedule at least once a week.

Sure, MA training is going to take some effort and time spent on your part, but in my experience it's all worth it.

Hey, I for one train on Friday nights when all of my friends are at the pub. I am willing to give up time spent with my friends because I don't have any other time and I value MA that much.

Posted by: BuDoc

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/29/05 11:42 AM

Stop making excuses.

You asked for help and help was provided. Much more than should have been.

If you want to learn Martial Arts, I mean really learn, you will find a way.

Everyone here finds a way. We all deal with real life. Jobs, kids,cars that break down, school schedules, wives that want to see you more, etc. etc.

It's about personal responsibility and drive. If you want it, go get it.

If you don't, that's ok too. Stay at home and whine about your situation. Just don't whine to us.

We all have problems. Most of us are willing to do as much as we can to help ourselves.

Page

Posted by: MN JC

Re: martial arts instruction - 06/29/05 02:10 PM

If you are not willing to sacrafice now you will not be willing to when your training is hard. So just sit back and wish your way to knowledge, I have never seen it work but hey, maybe you will be the exception.

I have four kids, a wife, work a full time job, rebuild houses on the weekends, and take classes/teach at our Dojo 5 times a week.

Set your priorities now and in life and then follow them.

Good luck