Posted by: McSensei
Inch perfect. - 08/19/05 05:51 PM
I was looking at a couple of highly respected karate clubs recently and realised that the attention to detail in the performance of their kata was conspicuous by its absence.
IE, front leg knee caving in while in zenkutsu dachi, back leg not straight in the same stance, punches landing at inconsistent heights, hips not fully engaged while punching and a whole host of other things that would get the "Do it again" from my instructors, yet not a mention in these 2 clubs. Most of the time the students were just encouraged to do it faster, with the resultant loss of good technique to a greater extent.
Do members feel that kata should be trained until it is inch perfect, but not bullet speed, or is it more important to learn the pattern to a reasonable standard, but fast and then move on to learn the applications. My own clubs philosophy on this is to train the kata to be inch perfect, (well almost) before looking seriously at applications. The theory being that if you can't do the techniques against an imaginary opponent you don't stand a cat in hells chance of performing them against a resisting one and that speed is not as important as good technique, timing etc.
Any thoughts?
IE, front leg knee caving in while in zenkutsu dachi, back leg not straight in the same stance, punches landing at inconsistent heights, hips not fully engaged while punching and a whole host of other things that would get the "Do it again" from my instructors, yet not a mention in these 2 clubs. Most of the time the students were just encouraged to do it faster, with the resultant loss of good technique to a greater extent.
Do members feel that kata should be trained until it is inch perfect, but not bullet speed, or is it more important to learn the pattern to a reasonable standard, but fast and then move on to learn the applications. My own clubs philosophy on this is to train the kata to be inch perfect, (well almost) before looking seriously at applications. The theory being that if you can't do the techniques against an imaginary opponent you don't stand a cat in hells chance of performing them against a resisting one and that speed is not as important as good technique, timing etc.
Any thoughts?